Log In


Reset Password
Archive

Majority Of Charter Proposals Won Panel's Unanimous Support

Print

Tweet

Text Size


Majority Of Charter Proposals

Won Panel’s Unanimous Support

By John Voket

(This is the first of a two-part story on the Charter Revision Commission’s progress to date as the panel prepares for its final public hearing on proposed revisions, scheduled for June 12.)

In just under a year’s time, six volunteer charter revision commissioners have held virtually every page of the town’s constitutional document up to the light, determining ways to make it more effective, more consistent, more efficient, and most importantly, more transparent.

Meeting in some configuration of four or more members on nearly two dozen Tuesday evenings since last summer, Chairman Al Cramer and Vice Chairman Joseph Hemingway, both former charter commissioners, and newcomers Joan Plouffe, Guy Howard, Carolyn Signorelli, and LeReine Frampton, also a town registrar of voters, have discussed some of the finer and more obvious areas of contention.

And while the occasional issue inspired brief disputes, according to information furnished by Mr Cramer this week, commissioners all agreed unanimously on supporting the vast majority of proposed revisions.

The charter panel is preparing to hear final public comment on proposed changes at a hearing tentatively scheduled for June 12. After reviewing any issues with the final draft of changes a week later, Mr Cramer is planning to turn the document and revisions over to the commission’s attorney to ensure all proposed changes retain the appropriate legal and permissible language.

Once the draft is provided to the commission’s attorney for review and editing, the hands-on responsibilities of the commission may be all but finished. Unless the panel is called back to reconsider votes already taken based on the outcome of legal and council reviews, the volunteers’ duties may be completed by the end of June.

In all, charter commissioners collectively ruled on 29 charges put forward by the Legislative Council, as well as ruling on 15 other points of clarification or revisions to date. Mr Cramer suggested at the commission’s last meeting that the panel may review some of its decisions or possibly consider additional concerns raised at the public hearing before calling a vote to submit the draft to legal resources June 26.

Term Lengths Intact

In late February, extensive discussion and public comment addressed term lengths for public officials. While commissioners previously unanimously supported a four-year term of office for the town clerk, it was not until February 27 that a super majority of 4-2 members supported retaining two-year terms for the Board of Selectmen, the Legislative Council, and the Board of Finance.

In all three cases, it was Mr Hemingway and Ms Frampton opposing the two-year terms, preferring instead four-year terms, which they both supported in each instance. That same evening, Commissioners Plouffe and Howard unsuccessfully opposed a motion to elect Legislative Council members in two districts instead of the current three.

Ms Frampton, who supported the proposal said by changing the council to two districts, each voter will have an opportunity to pick half the council.

“It will also take the voting out of the elementary schools — we will be in Reed and the middle school,” she said. “This will help with the safety of our young children during primaries and help lower the cost of elections. These polling places are also more accessible for the voters.”

The only other charges that drew any opposition included one to allow the town to manage its end-of-the-year budget surpluses. Mr Howard, who works in the financial services profession, said during discussion he wanted to see mare controls and stipulations applied to the proposal.

He was the sole commissioner who voted against the measure, which was lobbied for heavily by the town finance authority and Board of Finance members. Mr Howard also joined fellow commissioners Plouffe and Signorelli defeating a proposal to recognize and provide for the existence of the Fairfield Hills Management Authority.

The three commissioners opposing the measure argued that state statutes governing authorities and the enabling legislation in conjunction with a town ordinance authorizing the local board provided sufficient guidelines for the nonpolicymaking Fairfield Hills Authority.

Shortening Budget Processes

Mr Cramer was the sole commissioner opposing a revision recommending the annual budget process be shortened by two weeks. This would be accomplished by eliminating one public hearing and conducting a joint public hearing by the Board of Finance and by the Legislative Council, which is to occur before the Board of Finance recommends a budget to the Legislative Council.

The revision would also recommend the annual budget referendum take place on the second Tuesday in April, which would require rescheduling some date deadlines two weeks earlier.

Ms Frampton was the only commissioner supporting a proposal that all capital projects be subject to approval only once each year at the annual budget referendum, and that each project be listed separately on the ballot for voter approval or disapproval. The balance of the full commission voted against the proposal.

Four commissioners attending a May 8 meeting unanimously supported changing the name of the Board of Finance to the Finance Advisory Board. That move would remove state statutory protections and rights from this elected body and transfer all governing aspects to the charter and to local ordinance.

In a previous meeting, the four commissioners in attendance unanimously rejected a proposal to send defeated budgets back to the Board of Finance for review and recommendation before the Legislative Council considered further action.

On May 22, three initiatives failed by 3-2 votes. They included a proposal to put the position of town planner into the charter, to recognize the Water and Sewer Authority in the charter, and to place a long-range strategic planning committee in the charter.

Ms Plouffe, who introduced the planner proposal, said she was disappointed commissioners did not agree to propose a town planner and a long-range strategic plan in the charter.

“I believe that this failure commits us to a less efficient future, in which we will struggle to address issues in a haphazard manner, without the context of a professionally developed long-range plan,” she said.

Ms Signorelli said she was equally disappointed the commission was unable to agree that the town desperately needs a town planner.

“The only way to guarantee that Newtown receives the expert professional guidance it requires during its inevitable expansion and changing future needs was to include such a provision in the charter,” she said.

Commissioners Generally Pleased

Looking back on the process, Mr Cramer said he was pleased with the overall effort, although he recognized that the efforts put forth by commissioners constituted plenty of hard work reviewing what amounted to numerous points of “housekeeping” minutia, along with some sweeping changes potentially affecting highly visible aspects of the town’s government and operations.

“We had a lot of good discussion and met a lot of elected and volunteer representatives who were very helpful [providing input toward] decisions we were making,” Mr Cramer told The Bee this week. “Now we hope residents will come out to the hearing to let us know their final thoughts.”

Mr Cramer said anyone who cannot attend the hearing will have a final opportunity to address the charter commissioners during their final deliberations scheduled for June 26.

Mr Hemingway agreed with the chairman’s observations recognizing he and his fellow commissioners had some good debates and made some major changes as well as some minor housekeeping type changes.

“I think overall it has been a successful endeavor so far,” Mr Hemingway observed, adding that he hoped the council’s review and recommendations would keep the sum total of revisions somewhat intact.

“I hope once the Legislative Council reads the draft and makes their comments, if changes are to be made before the charter goes to the public for a vote, those changes can be agreed upon and the charter can be presented [to voters] as one document for approval or disapproval,” he said. “The last charter revision recommendations were split into four or five separate questions. Some passed and some didn’t, which created some confusion and redundancy.”

Ms Frampton said she supported issues shared by a majority of voters who approach her at the polls.

“I hope I spoke for what the voters have been looking for. I know there are some things they wanted, like a split budget, that I was not able to get through,” Ms Frampton said. “We put in a lot of hours and I hope we have made some positive changes.”

Ms Signorelli said she considered her work on the Charter Revision Commission to be extremely important.

“I am glad I was able to contribute to efforts to improve our Charter, and create a document that will increase the effectiveness and accountability of our town government,” she said. “I look forward to receiving input from fellow citizens during the public hearing and finalizing revision proposals that will hopefully be embraced by the Legislative Council and voters.”

Ms Plouffe pointed out that Newtown has experienced extensive growth in recent years and is projected to continue to grow at a rapid pace.

“The CRC has had the opportunity to help Newtown move beyond current procedures, while yet maintaining our values in this time of development,” she said.

Citing work and personal reasons, Commissioner Howard declined to comment for this article.

(Next week, Part 2 of this story will focus in part on a number of the unanimously proposed charter revisions that could have significant impact on the face and processes of Newtown’s government and operations.)

Comments
Comments are open. Be civil.
0 comments

Leave a Reply