40 Years Since The Disappearance Of Helle Crafts
An early snowstorm came through Newtown on the evening and into the early morning of November 18-19, 1986. Young Newtown Bee reporter Lisa Peterson, then Lisa MacFarlane, recalls staying in bed with her dogs to keep her warm as The Newtown Bee offices were closed, as was much of the town.
In the edition of November 21, 1986, The Newtown Bee wrote, “Newtowners awoke Wednesday morning to find that several inches of heavy, wet snow had accumulated, and power was out over most of the town.” It continued, “The storm brought the town to a standstill.” However, the scene at 5 Newfield Lane was not as still.
Living there at the time was Richard Crafts, an Eastern Airlines pilot and an auxiliary police officer with the Southbury Police Department; his wife Helle Crafts, a Danish national and Pan American flight attendant; and their three children. Also in the house was a live-in nanny, Dawn Marie Thomas.
“[Helle] was dropped off by a fellow flight attendant at her house,” Peterson explained, “and her last words to that flight attendant were, ‘Oh, Richard’s home.’”
Thomas was working her second job at McDonald’s, but when she came home, she noticed Helle’s car was in the driveway. Peterson added some of Thomas’ testimony from court: “She got up in the morning, the house was cold, the lights had gone out, the electricity had gone out because of the storm. Richard was anxious and running around saying, ‘We’re going to go to my sister’s in Westport, she’s got heat down there.’ And Dawn Marie Thomas is like, ‘Well, where’s Helle?’ And Richard told her, ‘Helle has left and she’s gone ahead.’”
Thomas remembered seeing footprints already in the snow, and Helle’s car was gone. She thought maybe Helle really had gone down to Richard’s sister’s house. Thomas and the children went to Westport and spent the day there. Richard returned to Newtown during the day and told everyone he was “working around the house.” Later that evening, Richard went and retrieved the three children and Thomas to bring them back to Newtown.
Peterson explained at this point, people were starting to ask where Helle was. He said she went to go visit her mother in Denmark, visit a friend in the Canary Islands, or that she was “with the kids.” Before she went missing, Helle had started to file divorce paperwork and hired a private investigator to document Richard’s years-long affair with a woman in a different state.
Keith Mayo, the private investigator, took Thomas down to the police station on December 1 and filed a missing persons report. Newtown Police then began working on the case. State police wanted to work on the case, too. Mayo did not think Newtown Police were doing enough for the case.
Thomas shared at one point that a carpet was removed from the master bedroom of the Crafts’ home, so Mayo tried looking for it.
“He starts looking where Newtown takes its garbage, we had a dump, but then they had to send the stuff to another dump … and he’s searching in the dump for days, and he finally comes up with what he says is the Crafts’ carpet. He takes it to the state police for analysis,” Peterson said.
Dr Henry Lee, a famous criminologist, looked at the carpet and said that it was not the carpet that belonged to Richard and Helle Crafts. The discovery of this carpet, however, “made a lot of noise in the media,” Peterson said. Mayo complained, “loudly,” to the state’s attorney, Walter Flanagan, who took the case away from Newtown Police and let the state police take it.
With the state police now managing the case, the same people were interviewed again. Then, on Christmas Eve, a Newtown Police detective, Harry Noroian, discovered that Richard had rented a commercial woodchipper on November 18 and put it on his credit card.
“Harry said to his fellow detectives, ‘I think he might have put her body through a woodchipper,’” Peterson shared.
While Snowstorm Carl was blanketing Newtown in snow, snowplow drivers were out clearing the roads the best they could. One interview with a driver led investigators to Silver Bridge. Along the shores of Lake Zoar, forensic experts found a total of ¾ of an ounce of Helle’s remains. They included 2,600 hairs, the tip of a toe, part of a finger, a dental crown with a small piece of bone, and several other small pieces of bone.
“You could hold all of it in your hand,” Peterson said.
Richard was arrested at 12:34 am on January 13 in 1987. The Newtown Bee wrote in the January 16, 1987 edition that Richard surrendered in his home without incident and was held at Bridgeport Correctional Center in lieu of a $750,000 bond.
State Attorney Flanagan said it was a “most unusual case” and that “there was no single piece of evidence that broke the case.” Peterson echoed this point — this case was the first murder conviction in Connecticut without a body.
Richard had a probable cause hearing on March 12. It took a whole year for the case to go to trial, and it was held in New London as everyone in the area was aware of the case. It was one of the longest trials in Connecticut history at the time, and included over 100 witnesses and nearly 200 exhibits. The jury deliberated for 17 days, but it resulted in a mistrial because one juror thought Crafts was innocent.
A second trial was scheduled for September 1989 in Norwalk, which is where the evidence for the case, including Helle’s ¾ ounce of remains, is still held. The second trial ran through November 1989, and the jury deliberated for about two to three days. The jury came back and delivered a guilty verdict. Crafts was sentenced to 50 years in prison without parole, and he was released in June of 2022 on good behavior.
“It’s a tragedy that he killed his wife, the mother of his three children, and then the manner in which he tried to conceal his crime was also horrific,” Peterson said. “This man had a very much cold, steely personality. I interviewed him in prison three times. He would never talk about the crime, he never talked about the case. He wanted to talk about his children, he wanted to talk about his lawsuits that were going on, his appeal that he eventually lost in 1993.”
Peterson said the last public thing she heard about Richard was that he was living in a halfway house after being released.
During her research, Peterson visited the Norwalk courthouse to sort through the evidence of this case. As mentioned, the very few remains of Helle are stored there. She said that she felt a “profound sense of sadness.
“This is all that’s left of her, and look where they left it,” Peterson shared.
Peterson calls this case a “snapshot in time.” She has learned a lot from it and how she handled her journalism, adding that it “changed [her] life.” It helped her move forward in reporting on Regina Brown, a Black Newtown woman who disappeared just two weeks after Richard’s probable cause hearing.
Peterson has since written a book about Brown and has drawn many similarities between Brown and Helle. They were both mothers of three, flight attendants married to pilots, and in the midst of a divorce. The only real difference was that Helle was white, and Regina was Black.
“I was guilty of the missing white woman syndrome as well,” Peterson said. “But this case changed my life … I was a young journalist, it was something I’d never experienced before. I was 25 years old when it first started. It made a lasting impression on me, and then Regina Brown has made a super lasting impression on me.”
The more Peterson looked at Helle Crafts’ case as she researched Brown’s case, she realized that the Crafts case “denied Regina Brown justice and denied her the investigation that she truly deserved.” Peterson pointed out that there was a very public call for an investigation into Newtown Police, which depleted public trust. She also thinks Brown’s husband, Willis, was researching the case because it was “almost the perfect murder.” Peterson also said that the police chief did not give investigators the time or resources to do a full investigation into Brown’s disappearance.
“It affected a lot of people’s lives beyond, obviously, the family, the children, but it affected a lot of people’s lives in law enforcement, in the criminal justice system. It was that far-reaching,” Peterson said.
While this case, as Peterson said, is a reflection of the time, she does not think it is a reflection of Newtown.
The editor of The Newtown Bee in 1987, Curtiss Clark, wrote in his editorial, which was placed next to the pictures of Helle and the Connecticut State Police Major Crime Squad van on the shores of Lake Zoar, “But what can we, as people living close to the scene of a terrible crime, really add to anyone’s understanding of murder? We don’t understand it any more than the remote television viewers … Our proximity to this crime hasn’t given us any useful insights. Our shock and confusion about the crime … hasn’t done much for the image of the town. But the reason we may seem so uncertain, so tongue-tied on camera, is that for most of us this new unflattering image of Newtown has very little to do with the reality of our town. We know it as a vital community where people care for one another.”
=====
Reporter Sam Cross can be reached at sam@thebee.com.
