Does Newtown High School have an American Idol, and, if so, who is it?

Skylar Ritter: Miles Aldrich.

Anastasia DeMarche: I’d say Miles Aldrich.

Ryan Wilkie: I would say Andrew Nichols.

Ashley Peck: Hannah DeFlumeri.

Casey-Rose Kernes: Hannah DeFlumeri.

Katherine Scott:  I have heard Katie McMoran is a really good singer, and she is in a lot of plays.